← All stories
Health information

[Dr. Song Sang-ho’s Walking Again: A Hip Journey] Do Robots and Navigation Systems Make Hip Replacement More Precise?

Robots and navigation serve the surgery rather than define it; what matters is getting length, offset and stability right

Dr. Song Sang-ho, Director of Wellton Hospital
Dr. Song Sang-ho, Director of Wellton Hospital · Supplied article materials

“Will a robot make my surgery more precise?”

It is a question patients preparing for joint replacement ask often. Robots and navigation systems can indeed contribute to a more accurate operation. They represent real progress: in addition to the surgeon’s experience and sense of touch, there is now a way to confirm conditions in numbers during the operation and to follow the surgical plan closely.

But what exactly are these tools meant to get right? Answering that requires a look at what joint replacement is meant to achieve in the first place.

What joint replacement aims for: the right length, offset and stability

A hip replacement involves far more than swapping a worn-out joint for an artificial one. The two legs must end up the same length, the joint must be rebuilt so the muscles around it can do their job, and the joint has to stay stable when the patient moves. These aims are summed up as restoring length, offset and stability.

In plain terms, offset means the sideways distance between the center of the hip and the thighbone. That distance determines the length of the lever the surrounding muscles pull on. Even if leg length is perfectly matched, the wrong offset can weaken muscle function and compromise joint stability, which is why these elements have to be considered as a whole.

Navigation is for checking, robotics is for carrying out

Both robots and navigation systems help surgeons reach these targets, though each contributes in its own way.

During the operation, navigation displays position, angle and changes in length as numbers. It supplements what surgeons used to judge by eye and by hand with objective data. Surgeons can see how far the actual situation departs from what they anticipated before surgery and, if there is a discrepancy, fix it while the operation is still under way.

In joint replacement, where even small deviations count, this is a significant benefit. Some information that once became available only on postoperative images can now be checked in the operating room. As long as the measuring conditions and the accuracy of the equipment are verified, navigation is a valuable aid to the surgeon’s decision-making.

Robotic systems, depending on the model, draw on these measurements and the surgical plan to help govern how much bone is cut or how instruments move. Their job is to help the surgeon reproduce the plan more consistently during the actual procedure. Certain functions also limit departures from the planned range and help spare bone and surrounding tissue that should be kept, though what a robot can do differs by device and by the part of the body being treated.

To put it briefly, navigation helps reveal the gap between where things stand and where the plan says they should be, while robotics adds precision to carrying out that plan. The two technologies overlap to some extent, and in practice both are used alongside the judgment of the operating surgeon.

Equipment is not the point; everything begins with a sound plan before surgery

The key is that using a robot or navigation system cannot be, and should not be, the reason for the operation. The reason is to give patients back the joint function they need, and equipment is worth only as much as it helps achieve that.

Getting there depends on a careful plan before surgery. Every patient has a different bone shape and size, a different degree of joint deformity, a different leg length and different muscle condition. Imaging is used to identify these differences, and the surgeon then decides which implant to place and where, in order to restore length and offset.

In the operating room, the surgeon checks whether that plan is actually being realized. When navigation reveals a change in length that was not anticipated, the reason is investigated and, where needed, the implant position or the choice of instruments is changed. Even with robotic assistance, the real state of the bone and soft tissue still has to be judged while the plan is executed.

Here, the surgeon’s experience and technique and the characteristics of the implant also play a large part. Precise measurement has to be followed by safe correction of any discrepancy. The surgeon must reach the intended length and offset while making sure the implant is firmly fixed and the joint moves smoothly.

The more surgical data builds up, the better surgery becomes

These technologies also matter because they leave behind a record that can be used to review and improve operations. Putting the preoperative plan, the measurements taken during surgery and the outcome side by side reveals at which step a difference crept in. As this record grows, it helps refine measurement techniques and surgical planning and supports knowledge sharing and training within medical teams.

Precise figures on a monitor, of course, are no guarantee of pain relief, good walking ability or patient satisfaction. Recovery depends on many factors acting together, such as the state of the muscles and tendons, other health conditions and rehabilitation. For the precision that technology provides to become genuine recovery, every phase of the surgical process has to be tightly linked.

The case for robots and navigation is straightforward: better planning before the operation, more accurate detection of discrepancies during it and precise correction of whatever needs adjusting. The right choice of implant, skilled surgical technique and evaluation after surgery build on top of that.

Taken together, all of these efforts aim to restore length, offset and stability with a little more accuracy and to use that accuracy to give patients better results.

And that is precisely why robots and navigation systems are used.

Questions and answers

Does robotic assistance make hip surgery more precise?

Robots and navigation systems can raise accuracy by letting surgeons confirm conditions in numbers during the operation and follow the plan closely. The equipment itself is not the goal, though; the surgeon’s judgment, the choice of implant and surgical technique all contribute.

What is the difference between navigation and robotics?

Navigation displays position, angle and changes in length as numbers during the operation, allowing the surgeon to spot and correct deviations from the plan. Robotics, depending on the system, governs how much bone is cut or how instruments move so the plan can be carried out more consistently.

In a hip replacement, what are surgeons trying to get exactly right?

Leg length, offset and stability. Offset is the sideways distance between the center of the hip and the thighbone, and even when leg length is matched, the wrong offset can affect muscle function and joint stability.

If the figures on the screen are precise, does that guarantee a good result?

No. Pain, walking ability and satisfaction depend on many things, including the state of the muscles and tendons, other health conditions and rehabilitation. Every step, from planning before surgery to evaluation afterward, needs to be tightly linked.

Editorial standards ↗

Continue reading